Recebi um e-mail de um aluno perguntando por que o verbo está no plural na seguinte frase:
“As is the case currently, a large portion of these are in Africa”
Essa é uma pergunta a respeito de subject-verb agreement. O Oxford Guide to English Grammar define subject-verb agreement como “choosing the correct singular or plural verb after the subject“.
Geralmente, a regra é: sujeito no singular, verbo no singular; sujeito no plural, verbo no plural. Entretanto, há vários casos específicos, como o caso da questão feita.
Quando o sujeito é composto por palavras que indicam porções (percent, fraction, part, majority etc.), é o substantivo – ou o pronome – da of phrase que segue que determina se o verbo deve estar no plural ou no singular. Se o substantivo estiver no singular, o verbo ficará no singular; se o substantivo estiver no plural, o verbo ficará no plural. Veja alguns exemplos, retirados do Grammarbook.com:
Fifty percent of the pie has disappeared.
Fifty percent of the pies have disappeared.
One-third of the city is unemployed.
One-third of the people are unemployed.
Isso já explica por que o verbo em “a large portion of these are in Africa” está no plural: ele está concordando com these, que também está no plural.
Entretanto, é importante notar algumas particularidades com relação a essa regra específica, principalmente no que diz respeito a quantifiers. Nesse sentido, o Oxford Guide to English Grammar traz algumas regras, as quais eu organizo na tabela que segue:
Expression |
Agreement |
Examples |
One of |
Singular |
One of these letters is for you. |
A number of The majority of A lot of |
Plural |
A large number of letters were received. The majority of people have complained. A lot of people have complained. |
The number of |
Singular |
The number of letters we receive is increasing. |
Amount of |
Singular |
A large amount of money was collected. |
Amounts of |
Plural |
Large amounts of money were collected. |
(Fractions) |
According to the Noun |
Three quarters of a potato is water. Almost half the plants were killed. |
Every and each and compounds with every, some, any and no
|
Singular |
Every pupil has to take a test. Each day was the same as the one before. Everyone has to take a test. Someone was waiting at the door. Nothing ever happens in this place. |
Each followed by a plural subject |
Plural |
The pupils each have to take a test. |
All and some with a plural noun |
Plural |
All the pupils have to take a test. Some people were waiting at the door. |
None of/neither of/either of/any of+ plural noun phrase |
Singular or Plural (Singular is more formal) |
None (of the pupils) has/have failed the test. I don’t know if either (of these batteries) is/are any good. |
No |
Singular or Plural |
No pupil has failed/No pupils have failed the test. |
Cheers!
Sources:
Eastwood, John. Oxford Guide To English Grammar. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002.